PDA

View Full Version : Chartuk Charges Dropped


Brookhaven Republican
05-13-2007, 09:47 PM
From the South Shore Press May 9, 2007

Now that the criminal charges have been dropped against former Brookhaven Parks Commissioner Bob Chartuk, it's time to say a few words about a man whose reputation has been unfairly attacked and whose many accomplishments swept under the rug.

As a retired public school counselor and administrator I focused some of my attention over the last few years on our local government, particularly the condition of our parks system. Projects never got off the drawing board, department morale was extremely low, and several of the most basic of repairs were never accomplished.

When I went looking for answers, Commissioner Chartuk was one of a few at town hall who found the time to meet with me and start turning things around. Bob showed up with a clipboard and took notes. He had that rare quality that I respect from our elected officials-He listened to what I had to say and shared my vision of how the town's parks should be.

After years of neglect, he made one of my favorite parks, West Meadow Beach, a priority and soon, the buildings were painted, bathrooms fixed, roofs repaired, and the sand piles, litter, and weeds in the parking lot removed. He saw to it that the rusted fences were replaced, sprinklers in the kiddie park fixed, benches and picnic tables cleaned and the parking lot repaired. We had hot water in the bathrooms for the first time in years. He took my suggestion on how to stop people from speeding through the parking lot and installed speed bumps. He even had the pulley fixed on the flagpole so we could finally raise the red, white, and blue.

Spending time with Commissioner Chartuk, we experienced what it takes to get something done in a bureaucracy and I saw first hand how much effort, skill, and integrity he put into the job. His results over four years were outstanding. He created a union-management partnership that put needed equipment, materials, and tools in the hands of the parks employees and they responded by dramatically increasing production. Morale turned around and the staff took great pride in thr work.

He used town employees, instead of expensive contractors, to do much of the work in building the 18-acre Heritage Park in Mt. Sinai, a project that would cost ten times the amount if attempted today.

He built new parks at Osprey Park in Mastic and Pine Lake in Middle Island and practically re-constructed the entire Mt. Sinai Marina, three environmental restoration projects that dramatically improved water quality. He was a commissioner that led massive environmental cleanups removing tons of garbage and debris from the town's open space holdings such the Orchard Neck Preserve in Center Moriches and he dredged the muck out of Senix Creek, not to mention a complete renovation of Neville Park in Center Moriches after decades of decay.

He managed the renovation of Great Gun Beach, Shirley Beach, and Kaler’s Pond Park in Moriches and remodeled the Mastic Recreation Center. He also tackled much-needed improvements at the Sweezey Avey House inYaphank.

He focused much-needed attention on the Longwood Estate, the town's historic cemeteries, Lake Grove Church, and even the Firemen's Memorial Park in Ridge which showed off its improvements by hosting one of the most successful fire tournaments in state history.

Across the town, parking lots were repaired, playgrounds renovated, and fencing at parks and ball fields replaced. He re-wrote service contracts and procurement specs for everything from plumbing supplies to grass seed saving the taxpayers thousands of dollars.

Above all, he was a family man who proudly brought his wife and daughters to park grand openings and town events. I'll never forget seng him working along side parks employees planting beach grass and trees and picking up litter. Due to his fairness and work ethic, he earned thr respect and support and they in turn worked hard for him and the taxpayers.

The list of Bob Chartuk's accomplishments goes on for many pages and I challenge any municipality on Long Island to match it. The District Attorney did a good job weeding out corruption in town government, but with Commissioner Chartuk, he went too far and I'm glad his case was discharged. To paraphrase a famous quote: Where does he go now to get his reputation back?"

Sincerely,


Paul Fnberg
South Setauket

HEALTH CLUB
05-14-2007, 09:08 AM
Sad But True. I Hope The D.a. Takes Out A Full Page Ad In Every Newspaper. I Am Glad The Charges Were Dropped-i Was Shocked To Hear They Were Even Out There To Begin With. I Am Sure The D.a. Did Not Want That Embarrasement ther So I Am Certain That They Worked Extra Hard To Be Certain That They Had To Drop Them Which Means They Did An Extensive Through Investigation.
I Am Happy For You Bob-you Deserve The Best. Good Luck

Chartuk 4 President
05-14-2007, 09:11 AM
Clean as a whistle! LOL

Unr
05-15-2007, 10:51 AM
Newsday reported Chartuk pled to a lesser charge and admitted everything in the indictment. How does that mean bng dropped?

health
05-15-2007, 11:05 AM
When did this happen?

Stony Brook Resident
05-22-2007, 03:58 PM
Here's the article, where does it say ALL charges have been dropped?



BROOKHAVEN Ex-official gets plea deal, Former parks chief to plead guilty only to a noncriminal violation in campaign contribution scandal
[NASSAU AND SUFFOLK Edition]



Newsday - Long Island, N.Y.
Author: ERIK GERMAN. erik.german@newsday.com
Date: Mar 1, 2007
Edition: Combined editions
Section: NEWS
Text Word Count: 321



Abstract (Document Summary)



[Robert Chartuk] will admit to everything contained in a 2005 indictment that charged him with allowing improper mining of town sand and seeking a campaign contribution in exchange - but he will plead guilty only to a noncriminal violation, said attorney Daniel Russo, of Patchogue.

While the specific charge to which Chartuk will plead has not been determined, it will leave him with no criminal record, Russo said. Chartuk also agreed to return the $750 contribution and cooperate with Suffolk District Attorney Thomas Spota's continuing political corruption probe, Russo said.

Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.



Buy Complete Document: Abstract Full Text

AGAIN, CHARTUK ADMITTED TO EVERYTHING INDICTED FOR, HOW DOES THIS MAKE HIM INNOCENT? HE JUST GOT A "GET OUT OF JAIL FREE CARD"

oh my oh hoiw
05-22-2007, 05:07 PM
welcome to suffolk county's court system. if anyone ever knew how corrupt it is, politicos getting a free pass wouldn't surprise you.

Village Times Reader
05-31-2007, 11:55 PM
You may have spent time with Chartuk, but other Three Village Residents have also and KNOW differently, especially the ones near Oxhead Road Community Park where he in a behind closed door agreement meeting secretly allowed the construction of an 83 car capacity parking lot to be constructed INSIDE the park, a failed plan (after local residents found out about it unlike the surprise of an industrial size parking lot) to construct public toilets with cesspools almost adjacent to some residents backyards. Before you speak so "highly" of Chartuk spewing words of decency and integrity, FOIL records to see just how honest of a person he really is. So in answer to your question, where does Chartuk go to get his reputation back? Those residents near Oxhead Road Community Park who had the misfortune of also dealing with Chartuk would most likely say, BEATS ME! As for myself, I would not want to buy a house from the real estate company that Chartuk is employed at.

Chartuk innocent-no way
06-04-2007, 07:13 PM
According to you, I guess Chartuk walks on water.....ok....although he admits to all the wrong doings on the inditement, his only punishment is to give back the "$750 bribe" he took, then who gave permission to the politically connected sports organizations using the constant excuse "it's for the children" to steal $450,000 worth of sand. Wasn't it reported Chartuk wanted to call the removal of the sand "excess materials? Or did chartuk's bosses say that? Those "bosses" on the town council making chartuk the scapegoat. $450,000 BUYS alot of votes! I'm sure Chartuk knows! Could he be guilty by association? Hey wasn't chartuk who reaped the reward of $450,000 dollar votes --he lost the primary for highway supv.!

Brookhaven Republican
06-06-2007, 10:02 PM
Janet Corley, miserable person of 363 Oxhead Road, Stony Brook, NY 11790--Give it a rest already.